Title: The Black Cloud
Title Record # 2355
Author: Fred Hoyle
Date: 1957-00-00
Type: NOVEL
Webpages: Wikipedia-EN
Language: English
User Rating: This title has no votes. VOTE
Current Tags: first contact (2), climate change (2), science fiction (2), england (2), philosophy (1), computers (1), astronomers (1), interstellar travel (1), music (1), higher intelligence (1), nebula (1), radio astronomy (1), genius (1), politicians (1), politics (1), Alien Communication (1), alien intelligence (1), astronomy (1), astromomers (1), astronomer (1), scientists (1), scientist (1), UK (1), hard sf (1), cosmic disaster (1) Add Tags
Author: Fred Hoyle
Date: 1957-00-00
Type: NOVEL
Webpages: Wikipedia-EN
Language: English
User Rating: This title has no votes. VOTE
Current Tags: first contact (2), climate change (2), science fiction (2), england (2), philosophy (1), computers (1), astronomers (1), interstellar travel (1), music (1), higher intelligence (1), nebula (1), radio astronomy (1), genius (1), politicians (1), politics (1), Alien Communication (1), alien intelligence (1), astronomy (1), astromomers (1), astronomer (1), scientists (1), scientist (1), UK (1), hard sf (1), cosmic disaster (1) Add Tags
Other Titles
| Translations | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Publications
Displaying all variants and translations • Do not display translations • Do not display variants or translations
| Title | Date | Author/Editor | Publisher/Pub. Series | ISBN/Catalog ID | Price | Pages | Format | Type | Cover Artist | Verif |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Black Cloud | 1957-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | William Heinemann | 15/-?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced
in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings
equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling.
Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g.
3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that
is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but
sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters
of a shilling). |
x+ 251 |
hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | Desmond Skirrow |  |
|
| The Black Cloud | 1957-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Harper & Brothers | $2.95?$: US dollar |
251 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | |||
| Die Schwarze Wolke | 1958-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Kiepenheuer & Witsch | DM 13.80?DM: German (Deutsche) mark |
271 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | |||
暗黒星雲?Ankoku seiun |
1958-00-00 |
フレッド・ホイル?Fureddo Hoiru |
法政大学出版局?Hōsei Daigaku Shuppankyoku |
332 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | ||||
| Det svarta molnet | 1958-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Albert Bonniers | 221 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | ||||
| Det svarta molnet | 1958-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Albert Bonniers | skr 16.50?skr: Swedish krona (crown) |
222 | tp?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep. |
novel | |
||
| The Black Cloud | 1958-07-00 | Fred Hoyle | Harper & Brothers / SFBC | $1.20?$: US dollar |
201 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | |
||
| De donkere wolk | 1959-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Hollandia | 227 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | Desmond Skirrow | |
||
| De donkere wolk | 1959-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Hollandia | 227 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | S. Pennink | |
||
| The Black Cloud | 1959-06-00 | Fred Hoyle | Signet / New American Library | S1673 | $0.35?$: US dollar |
191 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Richard Powers | |
| The Black Cloud | 1960-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books | 1466 | 2/6?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced
in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings
equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling.
Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g.
3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that
is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but
sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters
of a shilling). |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | John Griffiths | |
| The Black Cloud | 1960-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | William Heinemann | 5/6?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced
in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings
equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling.
Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g.
3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that
is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but
sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters
of a shilling). |
251 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | |||
| The Black Cloud | 1960-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books | 1466 | 2/6?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced
in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings
equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling.
Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g.
3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that
is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but
sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters
of a shilling). |
218+ [1] |
pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | John Griffiths | |
| La nube negra | 1961-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Compañia General Fabril (Los Libros del Mirasol) | 220 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | ||||
| La nuée de l'apocalypse | 1962-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Club français du livre | 292 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | Jacques Daniel | |||
| Le nuage noir | 1962-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Dunod |
x+ 225 |
hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | ||||
| A nuvem negra | 1962-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Edições GRD (Ficção Científica GRD #14) | 184 | tp?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep. |
novel | Eddie Moyna | |||
| The Black Cloud | 1962-10-00 | Fred Hoyle | Signet | D2202 | $0.50?$: US dollar |
191 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Richard Powers | |
| The Black Cloud | 1963-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books | 1466 | 2/6?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced
in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings
equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling.
Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g.
3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that
is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but
sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters
of a shilling). |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | John Griffiths | |
| The Black Cloud | 1964-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books | 1466 | 2/6?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced
in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings
equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling.
Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g.
3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that
is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but
sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters
of a shilling). |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | John Griffiths | |
| A nuvem negra | 1964-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Livros do Brasil (Argonauta #84) | 242 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Lima de Freitas | |||
| Die Schwarze Wolke | 1964-11-00 | Fred Hoyle | Heyne (Heyne Science Fiction & Fantasy #3033) | 3033 | DM 2.40?DM: German (Deutsche) mark |
170 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Richard Powers | |
| The Black Cloud | 1965-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Perennial Library / Harper & Row | P37 | $0.50?$: US dollar |
x+ 214 |
pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Charles & Cuffari | |
| The Black Cloud | 1965-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books | 1466 | 3/6?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced
in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings
equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling.
Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g.
3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that
is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but
sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters
of a shilling). |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | John Griffiths | |
| The Black Cloud | 1967-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books | 1466 | 3/6?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced
in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings
equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling.
Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g.
3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that
is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but
sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters
of a shilling). |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | John Griffiths | |
| The Black Cloud | 1967-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | William Heinemann | 25/-?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced
in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings
equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling.
Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g.
3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that
is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but
sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters
of a shilling). |
251 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | Desmond Skirrow | |
|
| The Black Cloud | 1968-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Signet / New American Library | P3384 | $0.60?$: US dollar |
191 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | |
|
| The Black Cloud | 1968-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books | 1466 | 4/-?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced
in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings
equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling.
Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g.
3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that
is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but
sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters
of a shilling). |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | ||
| Die Schwarze Wolke | 1970-04-00 | Fred Hoyle | Heyne (Heyne Science Fiction & Fantasy #3187) | 3187 | DM 2.80?DM: German (Deutsche) mark |
170 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Richard Powers | |
| The Black Cloud | 1971-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books | 0-14-001466-7 | £0.35?£: UK pound |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | David Pelham | |
| The Black Cloud | 1971-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books | 0-14-001466-7 | £0.35?£: UK pound |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | David Pelham | |
| The Black Cloud | 1971-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books | 0-14-001466-7 | £0.25?£: UK pound |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | |
|
| The Black Cloud | 1972-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | William Heinemann | 0-435-12047-6 | 249 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | |||
| The Black Cloud | 1972-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books | 0-14-001466-7 | £0.35?£: UK pound |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | David Pelham | |
| The Black Cloud | 1974-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | William Heinemann | 0-434-34919-4 | 261 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | |||
| De zwarte wolk | 1974-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Born (Born SF #60) | 90-283-0413-4 | ƒ6.50 | 187 | tp?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep. |
novel | Alex Jagtenberg | |
| The Black Cloud | 1975-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books | 0-14-001466-7 | £0.60?£: UK pound |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | David Pelham | |
| Die Schwarze Wolke | 1977-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Ullstein (Ullstein Bücher #3355) | 3-548-03355-5 | DM 4.80?DM: German (Deutsche) mark |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Hansbernd Lindemann | |
| The Black Cloud | 1978-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | William Heinemann | 0-435-12047-6 |
x+ 250 |
hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | |||
| The Black Cloud | 1978-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books | 0-14-001466-7 | £0.65?£: UK pound |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | David Pelham | |
| Die schwarze Wolke | 1978-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Ullstein (Ullstein Bücher #3355) | 3-548-03355-5 | DM 4.80?DM: German (Deutsche) mark |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Hansbernd Lindemann | |
| Le nuage noir | 1979-11-00 | Fred Hoyle | Néo (Fantastique / Science-fiction / Aventures #9) | 2-7304-0030-3 | 286 | tp?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep. |
novel | Jean-Michel Nicollet | |
|
| The Black Cloud | 1980-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books | 0-14-001466-7 | £0.95?£: UK pound |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Adrian Chesterman | |
| The Black Cloud | 1982-03-00 | Fred Hoyle | Signet / New American Library | 0-451-11432-9 | $2.25?$: US dollar |
191 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Paul Alexander | |
| The Black Cloud | 1983-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books | 0-14-001466-7 | £1.75?£: UK pound |
219 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | John Harris | |
| The Black Cloud | 1988-00-00 | Fred Hoyle | The Easton Press (The Masterpieces of Science Fiction) | 201 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | |
|||
| La nube negra | 1988-09-00 | Fred Hoyle | Ediciones B | 84-406-0164-6 | 245 | tp?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep. |
novel | Sergio Camporeale | ||
| The Black Cloud | 1998-04-00 | Fred Hoyle | Buccaneer Books | 0-89968-344-4 | 200 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | |||
| The Black Cloud | 2010-09-02 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books (Penguin Modern Classics) | 978-0-14-119640-4 | £9.99?£: UK pound |
viii+ 215 |
tp?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep. |
novel | |
|
| The Black Cloud | 2010-09-02 | Fred Hoyle | Penguin Books (Penguin Modern Classics) | 978-0-14-196749-3 | £6.99?£: UK pound |
ebook?Used for all electronic formats, including but not limited to EPUB, eReader, HTML, iBook, Mobipocket, and PDF. |
novel | |
||
| Le nuage noir | 2014-04-00 | Fred Hoyle | Éditions de l'Évolution (Science en fiction) | 978-2-36635-008-1 | €15.00?€: Euro |
311 | tp?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep. |
novel | ||
| The Black Cloud | 2015-01-13 | Fred Hoyle | Valancourt Books (Valancourt 20th Century Classics) | 978-1-941147-42-9 | $16.99?$: US dollar |
vi+ 226 |
tp?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep. |
novel | Lorenzo Princi | |
| The Black Cloud | date unknown | Fred Hoyle | William Heinemann | 15/-?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced
in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings
equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling.
Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g.
3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that
is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but
sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters
of a shilling). |
251 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | Desmond Skirrow | |
|
| The Black Cloud | date unknown | Fred Hoyle | Signet / New American Library | T5486 | $0.75?$: US dollar |
191 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | ||
| The Black Cloud | date unknown | Fred Hoyle | Signet | T5486 | $0.75?$: US dollar |
191 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | |
|
| The Black Cloud | date unknown | Fred Hoyle | Signet / New American Library | 0-451-07833-0 | $1.50?$: US dollar |
191 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | |
|
| The Black Cloud | date unknown | Fred Hoyle | Signet / New American Library | P3384 | $0.60?$: US dollar |
191 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | |
Reviews
- Review by Ken Slater [as by Kenneth F. Slater] (1958) in Nebula Science Fiction, Number 26
- Review by Leslie Flood (1958) in New Worlds Science Fiction, #68 February 1958
- Review by Anthony Boucher (1958) in The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, May 1958
- Review by R. S. Richardson [as by Robert S. Richardson] (1958) in Astounding Science Fiction, July 1958 , reprinted in:
- [as by Robert S. Richardson] Astounding Science Fiction, October 1958 (UK) (1958)
- Review by Hans Stefan Santesson (1958) in Fantastic Universe, August 1958
- Review by P. Schuyler Miller (1958) in Astounding Science Fiction, November 1958
- Review by Damon Knight (1958) in If, December 1958
- Review by Floyd C. Gale (1958) in Galaxy Magazine, December 1958
- Review [German] by uncredited (1959) in Utopia-Science-Fiction-Magazin, #24
- Review by P. Schuyler Miller (1959) in Astounding Science Fiction, November 1959
- Review by Frederik Pohl (1959) in If, November 1959
- Review
[German]
by
Arnulf D. Krauß?Arnulf D. Krauss(1965) in Pioneer, #21
- Review [Swedish] by Roland Adlerberth (1966) in Häpna!, Nr 1, (1966)
- Review by Richard Delap (1968) in Science Fiction Review, November 1968
- Review
[French]
by
Francis Valéry?Francis Valery(1980) in Fiction, #308
- Review by David Langford (1980) in Paperback Inferno, Volume 4, Number 1
- Review [German] by uncredited (1982) in Reclams Science Fiction Führer
- Review by Joseph Nicholas (1984) in Paperback Inferno, Volume 7, Number 4
- Review by Darrell Bain (2005) in My 100 Most Readable (and Re-Readable) Science Fiction Novels