Title: The Weapon Makers
Title Record # 878
Author: A. E. van Vogt
Date: 1947-00-00
Type: NOVEL
Series: Weapon Shops of Isher
Series Number: 2
Webpages: Wikipedia-EN
Language: English
Current Tags: science fiction (1), NESFA Core Reading List (1) Add Tags
Author: A. E. van Vogt
Date: 1947-00-00
Type: NOVEL
Series: Weapon Shops of Isher
Series Number: 2
Webpages: Wikipedia-EN
Language: English
Note: Clute and Nicholls give 1946 first publication and 1952 revision.
Bibliography in "The Best of A. E. van Vogt" (UK, 1974) also states 1946 first Hadley publication.
User Rating:
This title has no votes.
VOTE
Current Tags: science fiction (1), NESFA Core Reading List (1) Add Tags
Other Titles
Variant Titles | Translations | Serializations | Translated Serializations | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
Awards
Place | Year and Award | Category |
---|---|---|
3 | 2019 Retro Hugo | Best Novel |
Publications
Displaying all variants and translations • Do not display translations • Do not display variants or translations
Title | Date | Author/Editor | Publisher/Pub. Series | ISBN/Catalog ID | Price | Pages | Format | Type | Cover Artist | Verif |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Astounding Science-Fiction, February 1943 | 1943-02-00 | ed. John W. Campbell, Jr. | Street & Smith Publications, Inc. | $0.25?$: US dollar |
132 | bedsheet?8.5" by 11.25" magazines, e.g. early issues of Amazing; or the 1942-43 issues of Astounding. |
mag | William Timmins | ||
Astounding Science-Fiction, March 1943 | 1943-03-00 | ed. John W. Campbell, Jr. | Street & Smith Publications, Inc. | $0.25?$: US dollar |
132 | bedsheet?8.5" by 11.25" magazines, e.g. early issues of Amazing; or the 1942-43 issues of Astounding. |
mag | William Timmins | ||
Astounding Science-Fiction, April 1943 | 1943-04-00 | ed. John W. Campbell, Jr. | Street & Smith Publications, Inc. | $0.25?$: US dollar |
132 | bedsheet?8.5" by 11.25" magazines, e.g. early issues of Amazing; or the 1942-43 issues of Astounding. |
mag | William Timmins | ||
The Weapon Makers | 1947-00-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Hadley Publishing Company | $3.00?$: US dollar |
224 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | Allan Halladay | ||
The Weapon Makers | 1952-00-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Greenberg (A Corwin Book) | $2.75?$: US dollar |
220 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | Nettie Weber | ||
I Romanzi di Urania #17 | 1953-06-10 | ed. Giorgio Monicelli | Mondadori | 17 | Lit 150?Lit: Italian lira |
160 | digest?Digest-size magazine, including both standard digest size, at about 7" by 4.5", and also large digest, such as recent issues of Asimov's, which are about 8.25" by 5.125". |
mag | Curt Caesar | |
The Weapon Makers | 1954-01-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Weidenfeld & Nicolson | 9/6?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced
in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings
equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling.
Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g.
3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that
is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but
sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters
of a shilling). |
224 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | Pagram | ||
One Against Eternity / The Other Side of Here | 1955-00-00 | Murray Leinster, A. E. van Vogt | Ace Books (Ace Double #D-94) | D-94 | $0.35?$: US dollar |
186+ 134 |
dos?Dos-a-dos or tete-beche formatted paperback books, such as Ace Doubles and Capra Press back-to-back books. |
omni | Ed Valigursky , Stanley Meltzoff | |
Die Waffenschmiede von Isher | 1960-12-23 | A. E. van Vogt | Moewig (Terra Sonderband #36) | TSB36 | DM 1.00?DM: German (Deutsche) mark |
94 | digest?Digest-size magazine, including both standard digest size, at about 7" by 4.5", and also large digest, such as recent issues of Asimov's, which are about 8.25" by 5.125". |
novel | Johnny Bruck | |
The Weapon Makers | 1961-00-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Digit Books | R454 | 2/6?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced
in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings
equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling.
Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g.
3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that
is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but
sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters
of a shilling). |
156 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Ed Valigursky | |
Les armureries d'Isher / Les fabricants d'armes | 1965-10-30 | A. E. van Vogt | OPTA (Club du Livre d'Anticipation #2) |
xxvi+ 379 |
hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
omni | ||||
The Weapon Makers | 1966-00-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Ace Books | M-153 | $0.45?$: US dollar |
186 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Jack Gaughan | |
Urania #424 | 1966-02-20 | ed. Carlo Fruttero, Franco Lucentini | Mondadori | 424 | Lit 200?Lit: Italian lira |
184 | digest?Digest-size magazine, including both standard digest size, at about 7" by 4.5", and also large digest, such as recent issues of Asimov's, which are about 8.25" by 5.125". |
mag | Karel Thole | |
Die Waffenschmiede von Isher | 1967-09-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Heyne (Heyne Science Fiction & Fantasy #3102) | 3102 | DM 2.40?DM: German (Deutsche) mark |
174+ [1] |
pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Richard Powers | |
Die Waffenschmiede von Isher | 1969-00-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Heyne (Heyne Science Fiction & Fantasy #3102) | 3102 |
174+ [1] |
pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Richard Powers | ||
The Weapon Makers | 1970-02-00 | A. E. van Vogt | New English Library | 2536 | 5/-?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced
in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings
equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling.
Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g.
3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that
is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but
sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters
of a shilling). |
141 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Bruce Pennington | |
The Weapon Makers | 1970-06-00 | A. E. van Vogt | New English Library | 2536 | 5/-?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced
in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings
equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling.
Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g.
3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that
is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but
sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters
of a shilling). |
141 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Bruce Pennington | |
The Weapon Makers | 1970-11-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Tempo Books / Grosset & Dunlap | 5359 | $0.75?$: US dollar |
214 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Paul Lehr | |
Le armi di Isher | 1971-09-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Libra Editrice (I Classici della Fantascienza #5) | 5 | Lit 6,000?Lit: Italian lira |
606 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
omni | Allison | |
Les fabricants d'armes | 1972-00-00 | A. E. van Vogt | J'ai Lu (J'ai Lu - Science Fiction #440) | 307 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Tibor Csernus | |||
Les fabricants d'armes | 1972-00-00 | A. E. van Vogt | J'ai Lu (J'ai Lu - Science Fiction #440) | 307 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Tibor Csernus | |||
De wapensmeden | 1973-02-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Meulenhoff (M=SF #57) | 90-290-0335-9 | 196 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Frans Erkelens | ||
The Weapon Makers | 1973-04-00 | A. E. van Vogt | New English Library | 0-450-01527-0 | £0.30?£: UK pound |
141 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Bruce Pennington | |
The Weapon Makers | 1974-04-00 | A. E. van Vogt | New English Library | 0-450-01527-0 | £0.30?£: UK pound |
141 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Bruce Pennington | |
The Weapon Makers | 1975-00-00 | A. E. van Vogt | First Edition Library | 224 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | Allan Halladay | |||
Les fabricants d'armes | 1977-06-10 | A. E. van Vogt | J'ai Lu (J'ai Lu - Science Fiction #440) | 307 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Siudmak | |||
Le armi di Isher | 1978-06-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Editrice Nord (Cosmo Serie Oro. Classici della Narrativa di Fantascienza #33) | Lit 5,000?Lit: Italian lira |
xiv+ 454 |
hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
omni | Vincent Di Fate | ||
De arsenalen van Isher + De wapensmeden | 1978-09-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Meulenhoff (M=SF #56/57) | 90-290-0828-8 | 384 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
omni | Paul Lehr | ||
Die Waffenschmiede von Isher | 1979-00-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Heyne (Heyne Science Fiction & Fantasy #3102) | 3-453-30572-8 | DM 4.80?DM: German (Deutsche) mark |
205 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | ||
The Weapon Makers | 1979-02-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Pocket Books | 0-671-82267-5 | $1.75?$: US dollar |
190 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Jerome Podwil | |
The Weapon Makers | 1979-02-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Pocket Books | 0-671-82267-5 | C$1.95?C$: Canadian dollar |
190 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Jerome Podwil | |
The Weapon Makers | 1979-08-00 | A. E. van Vogt | New English Library | 0-450-04515-3 | £0.80?£: UK pound |
141 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Paul Monteagle | |
Die Waffenschmiede von Isher | 1980-00-00 | Alfred Elton van Vogt | Heyne (Heyne Science Fiction & Fantasy #3102) | 3-453-30572-8 | DM 4.80?DM: German (Deutsche) mark |
206 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Franco Storchi | |
Le armi di Isher | 1980-05-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Euroclub (Grandi Scrittori di Fantascienza #1,3/4) |
xiv+ 452 |
hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
omni | Cesare Reggiani | |||
De arsenalen van Isher + De wapensmeden | 1981-09-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Meulenhoff (M=SF #56/57) | 90-290-0828-8 | 384 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
omni | Paul Lehr | ||
Les fabricants d'armes | 1981-11-10 | A. E. van Vogt | J'ai Lu (J'ai Lu - Science Fiction #440) | 2-277-11440-5 | 307 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Siudmak | ||
Die Waffenschmiede von Isher | 1982-00-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Heyne (Heyne Science Fiction & Fantasy #3102) | 3-453-30572-8 | DM 4.80?DM: German (Deutsche) mark |
205 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | ||
Väktarna från Isher | 1982-00-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Delta (Stockholm) (Delta Science Fiction #148) | 91-7228-294-0 | skr 86?skr: Swedish krona (crown) |
185 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
novel | Eddie Jones | |
Les fabricants d'armes | 1984-11-15 | A. E. van Vogt | J'ai Lu (J'ai Lu - Science Fiction #440) | 2-277-11440-5 | 307 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Siudmak | ||
Les fabricants d'armes | 1987-12-07 | A. E. van Vogt | J'ai Lu (J'ai Lu - Science Fiction #440) | 2-277-11440-5 | 307 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Siudmak | ||
The Weapon Shops of Isher and The Weapon Makers | 1988-04-00 | A. E. van Vogt | New English Library | 0-450-42270-4 | £2.50?£: UK pound |
265 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
omni | ||
Ischer | 1989-01-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Heyne (Bibliothek der Science Fiction Literatur #73) | 3-453-03121-0 | DM 16.80?DM: German (Deutsche) mark |
508+ [8] |
pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
omni | Richard Powers | |
Les portes de l'éternité | 1990-02-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Presses de la Cité?Presses de la Cite (Presses de la Cité - Omnibus) |
2-258-03032-3 | F135.00?F: French frank |
lvi+ 857 |
tp?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep. |
omni | Alain Lambert | |
Les fabricants d'armes | 1991-03-22 | A. E. van Vogt | J'ai Lu (J'ai Lu - Science Fiction #440) | 2-277-11440-5 | 307 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Siudmak | ||
Făuritorii de arme?Fauritorii de arme |
1992-00-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Editura Nemira (Nautilus #003) | 973-95576-6-X | Lei 199?Lei: Romanian leu |
190 | tp?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep. |
novel | ||
Les fabricants d'armes | 1993-11-05 | A. E. van Vogt | J'ai Lu (J'ai Lu - Science Fiction #440) | 2-277-11440-5 | 307 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Siudmak | ||
Die Waffenschmiede von Isher / Die tote Stadt | 1995-00-00 | A. E. van Vogt, William Voltz | Das Beste (Unterwegs in die Welt von Morgen #145) | 3-87070-557-4 | DM 33.90?DM: German (Deutsche) mark |
351 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
omni | ||
Arsenalele din Isher. Făuritorii de arme?Arsenalele din Isher. Fauritorii de arme |
1998-00-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Editura Antet (Antet S.F.) | 973-8058-01-5 | Lei 12,00?Lei: Romanian leu |
288 | tp?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep. |
omni | ||
The Empire of Isher | 2000-06-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Orb / SFBC | 0-7394-1124-1 / 03318 | $11.98?$: US dollar |
352 | hc?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size. |
omni | Vincent Di Fate | |
The Empire of Isher | 2000-07-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Orb | 0-312-87500-2 | $14.95?$: US dollar |
352 | tp?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep. |
omni | Vincent Di Fate | |
Les marchands d'armes | 2003-02-03 | A. E. van Vogt | J'ai Lu (J'ai Lu - Science Fiction #6791) | 2-290-32568-6 | 523 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
omni | E. Gorinstein | ||
Hedrock l'immortale | 2006-11-00 | A. E. van Vogt | Mondadori (Urania Collezione #46) | 46 | €4.90?€: Euro |
298 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Franco Brambilla | |
The Weapon Makers | 2013-12-10 | A. E. van Vogt | Agency Editions | 978-1-940392-03-5 | $3.99?$: US dollar |
ebook?Used for all electronic formats, including but not limited to EPUB, eReader, HTML, iBook, Mobipocket, and PDF. |
novel | |||
The Weapon Makers | 2021-08-20 | A. E. van Vogt | Fiction House Press | 978-1-64720-408-2 | $17.95?$: US dollar |
226 | tp?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep. |
novel | Nettie Weber | |
The Weapon Makers | unpublished | A. E. van Vogt | Buffalo Book Company | $3.00?$: US dollar |
unknown?The publication record was created from a secondary source and the publication format is unknown. |
novel | ||||
The Weapon Makers | date unknown | A. E. van Vogt | Tempo Books / Grosset & Dunlap | 0-448-12126-3 / 12126 | $1.25?$: US dollar |
214 | pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
novel | Paul Lehr | |
The Weapon Shops of Isher and The Weapon Makers | date unknown | A. E. van Vogt | New English Library | 0-450-05122-6 | £1.00?£: UK pound |
141+ 127 |
pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
omni | Paul Monteagle , Paul Monteagle , Tim White | |
Tempo Science Fiction Library (Box Set) | date unknown | uncredited | Tempo Books / Grosset & Dunlap | #82015 | $7.75?$: US dollar |
184+ 214+ 248+ 256+ 208+ 310 |
pb?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper. |
omni | FMA |
Reviews
- Review by Walter Gillings [as by Thomas Sheridan] (1947) in Fantasy Review, June-July 1947
- Review by The Editor (1947) in Thrilling Wonder Stories, August 1947
- Review by P. Schuyler Miller (1948) in Astounding Science Fiction, May 1948
- Review by Groff Conklin (1952) in Galaxy Science Fiction, July 1952 , reprinted in:
- Galaxy Science Fiction [UK], No. 26 (1955)
- Review by Sam Merwin, Jr. [as by Sam Merwin] (1952) in Amazing Stories, August 1952
- Review by The Editors (1952) in The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, August 1952
- Review by P. Schuyler Miller (1952) in Astounding Science Fiction, September 1952
- Review by George O. Smith (1952) in Space Science Fiction, September 1952, (1952)
- Review by Joseph H. Crawford, Jr. and James J. Donahue and Donald M. Grant (1953) in '333': A Bibliography of the Science-Fantasy Novel , reprinted in:
- '333': A Bibliography of the Science-Fantasy Novel (1953)
- Review by uncredited (1954) in Authentic Science Fiction Monthly, #44 April 1954
- Review by The Editor (1955) in The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, May 1955
- Review by Groff Conklin (1955) in Galaxy Science Fiction, July 1955
- Review by P. Schuyler Miller (1955) in Astounding Science Fiction, August 1955
- Review [Dutch] by Eddy C. Bertin (1973) in Holland-SF 1973, #4
- Review by Loay Hall (1979) in Science Fiction & Fantasy Book Review, October 1979 , reprinted in:
- Science Fiction & Fantasy Book Review: The Complete Series, Vol. I, No. 1-Vol. II, No. 13, January 1979-February 1980 (2009)
- Science Fiction & Fantasy Book Review: The Complete Series, Vol. I, No. 1-Vol. II, No. 13, January 1979-February 1980 (2009)
- Review [German] by uncredited (1982) in Reclams Science Fiction Führer
- Review
[Swedish]
by
Bertil Mårtensson?Bertil Martensson(1982) in Nova Science Fiction - 4 1982
- Review [French] by Arnaud Brunet (2020) in Bifrost, #98